Productiv and Cledara both started in SaaS management, but they have taken very different paths. Productiv has repositioned around AI Portfolio Governance, focusing on shadow AI detection, AI risk scoring, and policy codification for enterprise IT teams. Its AI Visibility module scans your software portfolio to identify embedded AI features and assess data handling risks. With $73 million in funding and customers like Uber and Okta, Productiv is built for large organisations with complex, multi-department tech stacks. Cledara has stayed focused on the full SaaS management lifecycle: Discover, Buy, Manage, and Cancel. Its standout feature is issuing a unique virtual card per subscription, giving finance and IT teams payment-level control over every tool. Combined with accounting automation (Xero, QuickBooks, NetSuite), a Negotiation Copilot for renewals, and browser-based shadow IT discovery, Cledara is purpose-built for scaling companies with 30 to 500 employees. Both platforms carry a 4.6/5 rating on G2, but they serve fundamentally different needs. This comparison breaks down where they overlap, where they diverge, and which one fits your actual problem.